Call for Just Culture Taskforce core members to step down

As part of the establishment of the Healthcare Safety Investigation Branch, there was a proposal by the related Expert Advisory Group that there should be a national Taskforce on Just Culture:

https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_data/file/522785/hsibreport.pdf

It has become evident since the weekend that Jeremy Hunt has launched the Just Culture Taskforce by asking a small inner circle to kick off the process. The group say they will bring different thinking to transform NHS safety culture.

just-culture-twitter-profile

However, there has been no public consultation – or evidence of other due process – regarding the establishment of the Taskforce. I have called on the core group members of the Taskforce to support Just Culture by stepping down, and asking the Department of Health to start again from scratch, with proper public consultation.

The open letter calling for this was sent today and is provided below.

Dr Minh Alexander

NHS whistleblower and former consultant psychiatrist

LETTER

BY EMAIL via NHS Litigation Authority

Open letter to Martin Bromiley and other members of the Taskforce core group  24 January 2017

Dear Martin,

NHS Just Culture Taskforce

 I write as a member and a critical friend of the Just Culture Taskforce ‘movement’, having applied to join and having been accepted by Suzette Woodward of NHSLA.

I am writing to respond to your tweeted open letter. 1

It is very welcome that you now acknowledge there have been errors regarding the lack of diversity of the Taskforce. Indeed, your work on learning from errors and Human Factors is widely valued.

As the Just Culture Taskforce is a government instigated and publicly financed project, it is appropriate to re-visit Lord Keith’s comments on the importance of people being allowed to criticise the government:

“It is of the highest public importance that a democratically elected government body, or indeed any government body, should be open to uninhibited public criticism” 2

Many were mystified when the Just Culture Taskforce launched last weekend, with a twitter account and unofficial looking WordPress website. 3 The website gave very little information about the origins and nature of the project. The website stated that the Taskforce was ‘not an organisation’ but a ‘movement’. This was repeated in tweets and correspondence by Suzette Woodward. 4

After I asked questions by twitter and email 5 about the context of this initiative, you advised that:

  • The Department of Health was financing the Taskforce. This was also confirmed by Suzette Woodward, who added that the governance of the Taskforce lies with the DH 6, and that the DH would “support” the movement.4
  • You advised me that you and James Titcombe had been asked to initiate the process. You later added that you had been approached by a DH Deputy Director. Suzette Woodward added that the invitation in fact also came from Jeremy Hunt.

I asked you for the name of the DH contact. 7 I received no reply but I now gather that the two DH senior officials are members of the core group: Tim Jones Head of Patient Safety and Service Quality (formerly the DH Head of News) 8  and Paul Stonebrook DH Senior Policy Adviser. 9

As you may be aware, I have since formally asked the DH for information about terms of reference, how the Just Culture Taskforce was established, whether it is subject to DH Equality and Diversity policy, any identified outcome measures and arrangements for future transparency, as regards whether the proceedings of the Taskforce will be subject to Freedom of Information provisions. It would have been better of course if it had not been necessary to resort to FOI, or to have to do so again in future.

To my surprise, the Just Culture TaskForce’s website was subsequently arbitrarily edited, with substantial deletions. This is despite the fact that it is customary for official records to be transparent, and added to, not removed. Membership details of the core group have now been removed. To my great concern, I see that even the original NHSLA contact email address and contact portal have been removed.

Regarding your comment “..in deliberately sharing information at an early stage before the process had been better developed I created some confusion and suspicion”1, I do not think it was sharing of information that caused concern. It was that a group of individuals had been assembled to take this project forward without any evidence of due process, and without any public consultation. It was clear that important decisions had already been made about this project – such as adoption of a reportedly unconventional leadership model – without the involvement of all concerned. There was in fact a lack of information about many things. When I later requested information as a member of the ‘movement’10, I was told that it could not yet be provided. 11

I have flagged to you that I think the way in which the Taskforce was established so far is an example of club culture, even if the club lacks insight into this. You thanked me for doing so politely, but you disagreed.

In your open letter, you characterise the many objections raised so far about the Taskforce as “fear and mistrust”. 1 Rather,  I think it would be fairest to see them as evidence based arguments against the manner in which this project has been handled.

In all, I think the project has been poorly handled by the Department of Health. There is no evidence of staffside or whistleblower involvement from the outset. This is an extraordinary omission at a time when there are serious morale issues in the NHS. From the staff survey, we know that almost half of NHS staff do not feel confident that concerns would be properly addressed by their organisation. 12  Any effective project on Just Culture must involve staff and those with lived experience of suppression from the outset.

I am sure you entered into this project in good faith. I hope you can see now why the handling of this project has been inimical to Just Culture.

Whilst you, Suzette Woodward and the Taskforce website originally indicated that there would be a different leadership model, what is now clear is that there is a “core group” which has power, and is distinct to a “wider taskforce” (Suzette Woodward’s phrase) which anyone can join. 13 It does not matter that, as Suzette Woodward has maintained, you are not employees. 4 As members of the core group, you are all in a privileged position of influence and greater access to information about a nationally important project.

Accordingly, I call on all members of the current Taskforce core group to support Just Culture by stepping down and asking the DH to start again from scratch.

What is needed first is a process of totally open public consultation on what a Just Culture Taskforce should look like, how it should be established and how it should be governed. This is a highly sensitive, publicly funded government project, with ongoing contribution by senior DH officials. Thus, there needs to be clarity, real inclusiveness, fairness, structure and formality as to how its business is done.

With best wishes,

Minh

Dr Minh Alexander

cc Jeremy Hunt

Keith Conradi Chief Investigator Healthcare Safety Investigation Branch

All other members of the Just Culture Taskforce core group

AvMA

INQUEST

Katherine Murphy CEO Patients Association

RELATED ITEMS

https://minhalexander.com/2016/09/24/hot-air-about-just-culture/

https://www.opendemocracy.net/ournhs/minh-alexander/is-there-club-culture-at-heart-of-nhss-quality-regulator

REFERENCES

1 Open letter tweeted by Martin Bromiley 24 January 2017

martin-bromiley-open-letter-24-january-2017

2 Derbyshire County Council v. Times Newspaper Ltd. [1992] 1 Q.B. 770 at 809 and the leading opinion in the House of Lords in the same case, at [1993] A.C.534, Lord Keith of Kinkel at page 547E

3 Just Culture Taskforce twitter account: @JustcultureTF

Just Culture taskforce WordPress website: https://justculturetaskforce.com/

4 Tweeted copy of an email from Suzette Woodward, NHS Litigation Authority 22 January 2017:

tweeted-copy-of-email-by-suzette-woodward

Similar email from Suzette Woodward, NHS Litigation Authority 22 January 2017:

“Dear Dr Alexander

Thank you for your email.  I have just sent you an email answering your questions.  I have repeated them below:

The task force is not an organisation – it is a movement.  The task force is everyone working in the NHS – there is a small group of people who were invited by the Secretary of State and Department of Health to steer the work.

The Department of Health will support the movement 

The core group were invited to steer the work by the Secretary of State but as I say are not the task force and are not an organisation or employees. 

The aims are to conduct a listening exercise over the next year and then share what we have learnt in Spring 2018.

The core group will through the listening exercise meet and talk to every group including  NHS staff whistle-blowers – who if they join the movement will be part of the whole task force.

The Just Culture taskforce came about because of a public document by the Expert Advisory Group who recommended this to the Department of Health

To assure the patient groups and others on this email list – we will be engaging with you all in this process – it is very early days and we will inform you as we progress.

Kind regards

Suzette

Dr Suzette Woodward

National Campaign Director

Sign up to Safety”

5 Email to all members of the Just Culture Taskforce 22 January 2017

“To all members of the Just Culture Task force for the NHS in England 22 January 2017

 Dear All,

Can I ask how this task force is financed, whether its accounts will be published and which NHS body is overseeing or has stewardship of this project?

Could you also let me know how the members of the taskforce were appointed, and by whom, and what the selection criteria were?

Do you have terms of reference and any timetable for your work? If so, could these be shared?

Also, I don’t see (to my knowledge) that there are any NHS staff whistleblowers in this group. This seems an extremely serious omission. Please could you explain why this is so, and if you agree that it was an omission, whether you will now put that right? If so, how?

I have to say that a Just Culture taskforce that is assembled without public consultation is something of a contradiction in terms.

Yours sincerely,

Dr Minh Alexander 

cc Katherine Murphy CEO Patients Association

    AvMA

    INQUEST”

 

6 Tweet 22 January 2017 by Suzette Woodward NHS Litigation Authority

suzette-woodward-dh-governance

7 Tweeted question about the name of the Department of Health contact:

q-about-dh-contact

8 Tim Jones

http://www.prweek.com/article/1175503/department-health-defends-london-pr-spend

https://www.linkedin.com/in/tim-jones-987a1b134

9 Paul Stonebrook

https://www.linkedin.com/in/paul-stonebrook-bb1ab9104

10 Email 22 January 2017 to Suzette Woodward NHS Litigation Authority

“To Suzette Woodward, National Campaign Director, Sign Up to Safety 22 January 2017

Hi Suzette,

Thanks for your email – or the screenshot of your email (below). I’m not sure what happened as I gather some cc’d people received a copy of your reply, but my copy never arrived.

Notwithstanding, I gather from your tweets that anyone can join your movement.

I’d like to join your movement, thank you.

What happens now and who’s making the decisions about how I can contribute?

Who’s doing the organising/ admin, that I can link with?

Best wishes,

Minh

cc All other Task force members

    AvMA

    INQUEST

    Katherine Murphy CEO Patients Association”

11 Email 22 January 2017 from Suzette Woodward NHS Litigation Authority

“Dear Minh

Thank you.  That’s great.

We are building up the list of interested people and would be really keen to involve you.

At the moment because we have literally just started we are still working through the details as I think you have probably seen on twitter today 

We will be in touch soon.

Kind regards

Suzette

Dr Suzette Woodward

National Campaign Director, Sign up to Safety

Twitter: @suzettewoodward”

12 Annual NHS staff survey 2015

“Fifty six percent of staff had confidence that their organisation would address their concerns if they were raised.”

http://www.nhsstaffsurveys.com/Caches/Files/20160322_NHS%20Staff%20Survey%202015%20National%20Briefing_V2.pdf

13 Tweets on 22 January 2017 by Suzette Woodward, NHS Litigation Authority

suzette-woodward-wider-taskforce

suzette-woodward-tweets

One thought on “Call for Just Culture Taskforce core members to step down

  1. I wish everyone well with their movements.

    I must be honest and admit that I only scanned your article and thus I am even less qualified to comment than usual. However, from what I can see we have perennial problems right from the start.
    And it’s from the start that problems should identified, addressed and eliminated.
    Oh, dear.
    I wish everyone, who has good intentions and appropriate competencies, well.

    Kindest,
    Zara.

    Like

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s